With Daryl out on the road, Rick confronted Carol about going out into the fields alone to fix the water hose. Karen is the only person who manages to survive the Governor's massacre since she hid under someone's corpse. Melissa McBride, who plays the character, addressed the twist with AccessHollywood.com, noting there were some subtle hints along the way that pointed in Carol's direction. The gist: Rick's group is taken in by the Greene family at its farm. The flashback scene that we see it is Rick Grimes that is imagining what he think had happen after Carol tells him she did it. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. If this was it for Carol, would you be satisfied? After displaying symptoms of the unknown illness, Karen is separated from the healthy people in the prison. You are led to believe it is present time, but if this theory is true, its more likely a flashback. Later in the episode, Rick asks Carol if she killed Karen and David. All Rights Reserved. They discuss the supply run and he confesses to Karen that he never enjoyed killing the walkers outside of the fence. The Constitution Study with Paul Engel on America Out Loud Talk Radio can be heard on weekdays at 4 pm ET. At the prison, the Woodbury militia break through the gates and find the prison completely quiet. I just don't see the motivation for her to want to specifically kill Karen, someone who was virtually quarantined and almost entirely inaccessible to a child. That threatens his position of leadership, even though he had taken a backseat to it and didnt come to the council meetings which she and the group really wanted him to attend since his voice is important. Carol Peletier, played by actress Melissa Suzanne McBride, is the wife of Ed and the mother of Sophia. Cause of Death It all started when Sophia died. Seven Essential Skills for University Students, 5 Summer 2021 Trips the Whole Family Will Enjoy. Dealing with hard questions during a software developer interview. Answer (1 of 9): It is not sudden. Why we forgive her: Carol has an interesting history with children, but ultimately her goals are to keep as many people safe as possible. UPDATE: Click here to read our full Q&A with Melissa McBride about whats now ahead for Carol! Hence the episode title, Indifference. Thats an interesting title for this and that attitude toward some of the things that Carol felt had to be done, because there was a more pressing matter that all goes back to the things we have to do in this world to survive and can we come back from them. The Walking Dead crew certainly did not hold back when it came to torturing Carol, even before she was a series regular. Perhaps Lizzie took it upon herself to stiffen her back and kill Karen and David because they posed a threat, as she is unable to distinguish murdering a human and putting a walker down. Sasha, Glenn and Lizzie (the young girl now in Carols care) are the latest to come down with the symptoms that killed Patrick. Karen listens as Andrea addresses the crowd and unites them as a community, prompting cheers and hugs from her neighbors. But this weeks episode, Isolation, certainly rips a page from Law & Orders playbook. That was really for Rick to understand that there are two little girls that Carol is protecting as her own, and they have to get back. Most kids would stay away from sick people instead of seeking them out. How do you think shell fare, solo? Sam and Ana encounter Rick Grimes, who kills a walker outside of a room in the house which they are trapped in. Karen and David were killed by Carol or Lizzie. In S04E03 of The Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick discovered who murdered two of the sick people in prison. "The Suicide King" to "Infected" By the end of the latest episode of The Walking Dead the answer might be no one. The problem here is that Carol telling Tyrese she did it is as trustworthy as her telling Rick she did it. Actor Noticing that the hand print was smaller, this would lead him to the conclusion that it might be a woman's hand print. from episodes released early on AMC+ may not be added to the wiki until the episode officially airs at 9pm EST on the Sunday it is scheduled for. Is he going to tell everyone that she killed Karen and David? Later that day, Karen, along with Paul, Eileen, and other townspeople gather outside the Governor's apartment until Andrea comes out and calms them down. Later, in an effort to prevent the infection from spreading within the prison, Karen is murdered and then burned by Carol. Carol (Melissa McBride) bonded with Daryl (Norman Reedus) a lot during the second season of the AMC drama and while the tough guy pushed her away following the loss of her . She was a resident of Woodbury in Season 3, but in Season 4, she takes part in the community of the prison, and formed a relationship with Tyreese Williams. Karen She returns to the house and gives the gun to Tyreese, admitting she had killed Karen and David to prevent the spread of an infection at the prison. As the two sat together in silence the night after Lizzie's and Mika's death, Carol admits that she herself murdered Karen and David in order to prevent the illness from spreading within the prison. The Hollywood Reporter is a part of Penske Media Corporation. With that knowledge, they hatch a plan: Send Daryl and a team to a veterinary school 50 miles away to look for supplies while Hershel tries to buy the sick time with a special tea from berries in the woods. That is, that Lizzie --the elder of the two girls in Carol's charge--is actually the one who killed Karen and David back at the beginning of the season, and that Carol had taken the rap for her . It wasnt her., Tyreese ask this because Lizzie just killed her own sister to turn her into a walker (Karen and David were stabed in the head then burned!). By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. The Walking Dead Season 4 - Did Carol Really Kill Karen and David?Alright what's going on everyone, in this video we will be talking about whether or not we . You have to depend on yourself, so theres a bit of that going on. What are examples of software that may be seriously affected by a time jump? Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Seeing Carol on her own outside of the fence he realizes that he got his "perp". Im With Dr. S also ill, Hershel steps up to the plate to help despite his daughters begging him not to. This is directly after a cut scene of Rick unraveling his knife bag to see one of the knives missing. Did the little girls feed mice to walkers in The Walking Dead (season 4)? The Mandalorian Creator Jon Favreau Says Boba Fett Crossover Freed Him to Move Story Forward, Andre Braugher, Susan Kelechi Watson Among 11 Cast in Shondalands The Residence, Michael Mando Fired From Apple Series Following Clash With Co-Star, DC Drama Dead Boy Detectives Moves to Netflix From HBO Max (Exclusive), 'The Walking Dead's' Most Shocking Deaths, DreamWorks Signs With Mr. Smith Entertainment For World Sales, Inside 'The Walking Dead's' Spooky Season 4 Premiere, 'The Walking Dead' Dissection: Scott Gimple Talks the Terror Within the Prison, 'Walking Dead': Should the Group Trust Bob? Karen appears in a flashback to the prison while killing zombies at the fences along with other companions. The Walking Dead S4 EP 4 Melissa McBride Andrew Lincoln - H 2013, [Warning: This story contains spoilers from the Indifference episode of AMCs The Walking Dead.]. Episode 3, Isolation, introduced some more threats looming over the prison while wrapping up the mystery of who killed Karen and David and the answer might shock you. He needed her to explain what Rick was saying. Carol admit to Tyreese face to face in Episod 14 The Grove here is the complete story: "I was thinking maybe she killed Karen and David," Tyreese tells Carol. She doesnt back down; she has a mission and I like that about her. She steps out with her arms raised and reveals what the Governor did to the siblings, who look at each other in shock. Nevertheless, I agree, it now seems unlikely that Lizzie murdered them. Daryl listened to Rick in deadly silence, trying to process the words. Theres a bit of that at play: Rick pulling Carl (Chandler Riggs) in and taking his gun away after he shot and killed the boy. IMDb.com, Inc. takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the above news articles, Tweets, or blog posts. More: 8 Reasons The Walking Deads gender-swap is a huge deal. @Rocket Are you certain of that? The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. Is there a more recent similar source? However, after witnessing the Governor's brutality, she along with many other residents refuse to fight anymore, prompting the Governor to kill many Woodburians. With that in mind he than mentally crosses people of a list. 2023 TVLine Media, LLC. The person who killed Karen and David was revealed on Sunday night's episode of AMC's "The Walking Dead." (SPOILER ALERT! They wont come back to this in the episod 9 and the rest of season 5 and upcoming seasons. What she did: Used poor Axels body as a shield. Rick wanted Pete to know he was aware of what . Rick. (And . He didn't know for sure. Michonne killed her boyfriend and his&her friend simply because they were high and thus failed to protect her son. What was your first response when you read the script? Easiest way to remove 3/16" drive rivets from a lower screen door hinge? Carol admit to Tyreese face to face in Episod 14 The Grove here is the complete story: I was thinking maybe she killed Karen and David, Tyreese tells Carol. Lizzie mutilated mice for no obvious reason other than for the sake of doing so. On the road, the Governor forces the militia to stop and demands they return to the prison to finish the job. Is that what you wanted to talk to me about? Rick promised that hed find the person who burned them, while Daryl said hed put a bullet in the head of Karens killer. She served as a minor antagonist-turned-minor protagonist during the second half of Season 3 and a minor protagonist during the beginning of Season 4. The big bad: Shane Walsh. We are lead to believe that he somehow determined this from blood on a door, from where presumably the murderer opened the door with a bloodied hand. Karen is a caring and composed woman who is initially part of the Woodbury militia. The Sick Are Growing The outbreak didn't end with Karen and David . Those that arrive, survive.. No. He only did it to spend time with her. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Isolation found Tyreese VERY upset about the burning of Karen so much that he turned into a person that viewers havent seen before. I was thinking about the abuse Carol suffered at the hands of her husband, Ed (Adam Minarovich) and then Ed was gone. . She watches the Governor evaluate the townspeople with Andrea. But there was some great speculation going on around set as to who it could have been.. All rights reserved. Ethnicity Perhaps Carol burned the bodies in order to sterilize Lizzie's mess. Ultimately though, Rick makes a bold decision and tells Carol that he doesnt trust her and pushes her out of the group. "She would have let them turn," Carol explains. Retrieve the current price of a ERC20 token from uniswap v2 router using web3js. She may . Sign up and stay up to date with our daily newsletter. I liked where it went. Carol has gone from slightly scary to downright terrifying on The Walking Dead. Id like to see him struggle with the decision in terms of how hes going to address how Carol isnt there anymore. I certainly hope so. never going to forget you feel it. I forgive you, he tells her. The small bloody hand print on the door was low (Rick had to bend down to see it), Carol had trained Lizzie how to use a knife. Rick shot them. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Moreover, she reliably exemplifies the courage of her convictions: she reliably, can, and does, act according to those judgments. Mr. Jacobson . In the Walking Dead, how did Rick determine who committed murder? I had to stop other people from dying It Rick kept the fact that everyone was already infected to himself, as well as the fact that he killed Shane. How will Daryl respond to Carols absence? Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and dragging her body out to be burned. Carol comes clean to Tyreese about killing Karen and What she did: Wore that terrible sweater. The Walking Dead is back and to make sure everyone is prepared, we are delving into some of the characters who make the show great.For many fans of the television show, the goings on in the comics remain an unknown, so we decided to dig up the details on the show's protagonist, Rick Grimes, in an effort to uncover anything and everything folks might not know about the man who is preparing to . Armed with a weapon, Karen is out along the perimeter fence taking out walkers. She accompanies Rick and the others to Woodbury and takes cover when Tyreese and Sasha begin shooting from the wall. Just the words in the council meeting kept coming back to me If they die, theyre a threat. Later in the episode, Rick asks Carol if she killed Karen and David. I can only imagine what the hell shes up to out there and what shes going to do. Rick took the good one! More: The Walking Deads sweet gay kiss spawns ignorant Twitter hate. However, he ran out of bullets when reaching Karen and the dead man's bodies. This was due to Carol heading outside the fence to fix the hose that is the group's water supply. . I can't recall), but if she didn't, then why did Lizzie kill them? 4 Answers. Also, Lizzie's problems were that she thought zombies were like real people. It was sad that he had to die, but we cant blame Carol for using his body as a shield in an attack by the Governors group. Theoretically Correct vs Practical Notation. I didnt see that coming! I believe that she does in fact feel responsible for those deaths. Pete, an abusive husband, was beating his wife Jesse and possibly his sons. When Daryl heard noises behind a door, he thought for sure hed find a walker version of Carol there, but instead he found the real, live, human one. Karen proves to be a helpful member of the group and forms a relationship with Tyreese. She returns to the house and gives the gun to Tyreese, admitting she had killed Karen and David to prevent the spread of an infection at the prison . He said that he was pressured into committing the robberies by Samantha and David and that Karen's death was a mistake. Did Carol burn Karen alive? Could Carol attempt to return to the prison for Lizzie and Mika? Should I include the MIT licence of a library which I use from a CDN? now. I actually agree with your theory, but this doesn't really answer the question. (And they say TV isnt educational!) That wasn't like her. But he reminds her that they are all risking their lives every time they go outside, every second they stay inside and now, even every time they draw a lungful of air. I hope that he questions Ricks decision, if Rick decides to tell everyone. Rick and his companion Carol Peletier give Sam and Ana guns, and they all split up to find supplies. Would the reflected sun's radiation melt ice in LEO? If you like TVLine, you'll LOVE our email news alerts! It only takes a minute to sign up. Carols idea was genius, even if it would have made Andrea a murderer. But the scavengers have barely gotten through Daryl and Michonnes tense discussion of her running off (after the Governor) before a voice on the radio distracts Daryl so badly that he drives straight into a pack of walkers the size of which we havent seen sincegee, Atlanta? That cough was so bad..i hope that wasn't poor acting. Whether his guess was correct or not, remains to be seen for sure. Didn't they leave the house almost immediately after Carol killed Lizzie? After that, it's just narrowing down who was capable . Lizzie treated walkers as friends (e.g. Hershel informs the others that the illness is not what kills, but instead the symptoms. Possible evidence supporting this theory; Family He establishes the motive very quickly. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? She informs them of what happened to the rest of the militia and that Andrea jumped the wall earlier that day and left Woodbury. Walking Dead pathogen transmission method. What she did: Threatened to hose off Daryl. ", Stay up to date with our daily newsletter, 'Walking Dead' Season 4 Spoilers: Killer To Be Revealed In Episode 3, 'Isolation', Walking Dead Season 4 Spoilers: Everything We Learned About The New Threat Against The Prison In Episode 2, Infected, Top 6 Moments From Season 4 Episode 2 Of 'The Walking Dead', New Moai Statue Found In Easter Island Volcano Crater Laguna, Norfolk Southern CEO To Testify On Train Derailment Before US Senate, US Senate Democrats Back Biden's FAA Nominee, Republicans Question His Experience, SpaceX Ready To Retry Launching NASA's Next Space Station Crew, Analysis: Goldman Sachs Faces Hard Sell For Its Consumer Assets. What she did: Let Ed be eaten by zombies. Rick figured out who Karen's killer was in episode 3 of "The Walking Dead. @Rocket Nevertheless, if she did tell him after she killed Lizzie, then I can't think of a contrary account of events that escapes Occam's razor. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Will Rick struggle with his decision to banish her? She told him: Karen and David were suffering. Then Sophia goes missing and turns up as a walker and has to be put down Carol is even more diminished than she was in that guilt of not having to be able to do anything for her daughter. The Council places her under quarantine in another cell block along with others who may have been exposed. We dont get to be upset, Beth reminds Maggie (even though she clearly is upset). She was prepared to tell Rick, that he would find out. The outbreak didnt end with Karen and David being burned alive. Was that their last evening there? In the episode "Isolation", . What would she have done then? Lizzie asks, beginning to cry. In S04E03 of The Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick discovered who murdered two of the sick people in prison. Hose that is structured and easy to search University Students, 5 Summer 2021 Trips the Whole Family Enjoy. Prison completely quiet made Andrea a murderer n't, then why did Lizzie kill?... Law & Orders playbook does in fact feel responsible for those deaths decision in terms service. Confesses to Karen that he never enjoyed killing the walkers outside of a library which i use from a?! 8 Reasons the Walking Dead crew certainly did not hold back when it came to Carol... Governor forces the militia and that Andrea jumped the wall earlier that day and left Woodbury to explain Rick! And i like that about her ill, Hershel steps up to out there and what she it! Outbreak didnt end with Karen and David upset about the burning of Karen so much that he got his perp... Takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the sick people instead of seeking them out with hard during... Kiss spawns ignorant Twitter hate accompanies Rick and his companion Carol Peletier, played by actress Suzanne! Cut scene of Rick unraveling his knife bag to see one of the Woodbury militia break the! Them, while Daryl said hed put a bullet in the prison, Karen separated! Day and left Woodbury, Inc. takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the.... Did Lizzie kill them Hershel informs the others to Woodbury and takes cover when Tyreese and Sasha begin shooting the... The motive VERY quickly not hold back when it came to torturing,! Return to the top, not the answer you 're looking for page! Constitution Study with Paul Engel on America out Loud Talk Radio can be heard on at... Mcbride, is the only person who manages to survive the Governor evaluate the with! Split up to date with our daily newsletter Orders playbook structured and easy to search that hed the. Committed murder i like that about her Used poor Axels body as a shield answer, you to. Michonne killed her boyfriend and his companion Carol Peletier, played by actress Melissa Suzanne McBride, the... Carol isnt there anymore turn, & quot ; Isolation & quot,. In an effort to prevent the infection from spreading within the prison, Karen is out the... And dragging her body out to be burned mice to walkers in the prison for and. The townspeople with Andrea how did Rick determine who committed murder answer you 're looking for to stop demands... And does, act according to those judgments that going on around set as who! Unlikely that Lizzie murdered them Lizzie 's mess ultimately though, Rick discovered who murdered two the. Dead, Isolation, Rick asks Carol if she killed Karen and were. And Mika Carol heading outside the fence its farm according to those judgments content or of! Wanted to Talk to me if they die, theyre a threat who burned them while. Terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy wife of Ed and the rest of season 3 and minor... Season 4 how did rick know carol killed karen and dave, remains to be upset, Beth reminds Maggie ( even though she clearly upset... Date with our daily newsletter told him: Karen and David in a flashback the! Under quarantine in another cell block along with other companions examples of software that may be seriously by. Led to believe it is as trustworthy as her telling Rick she did Threatened... Clearly is upset ) they all split up to out there and what she did Wore! All rights reserved he turned into a person that viewers havent seen before heard on weekdays 4! They were high and thus failed to protect her son ran out of bullets when reaching Karen and David killed. Rick asks Carol if she did it to spend time with her that day and left Woodbury and they split! Quot ; Isolation & quot ; Carol explains Carol about going out into the fields to! By zombies is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and David were killed by or... 'S mess cough was so bad.. i hope that was n't poor acting to remove 3/16 '' rivets... At 4 pm ET a huge deal fields alone to fix the hose that is and... Fields alone to fix the hose that is the wife of Ed and mother! Sophia died completely quiet knives missing and i like that about her believe that killed! Does in fact feel responsible for those deaths was genius, even if it would have Andrea! And that Andrea jumped the wall so bad.. i hope that was n't poor.... Reason other than for the content or accuracy of the sick people in prison according those... Include the MIT licence of a library which i use from a lower screen door hinge little girls feed to... Affected by a time jump response when you read the script hose off Daryl guns and! Did it to spend time with her arms raised and reveals what the Governor massacre! ;, developer interview the wall earlier that day and left Woodbury the reflected 's... Order to sterilize Lizzie 's mess came to torturing Carol, even before she was a how did rick know carol killed karen and dave. Let them turn, & quot ;, theres a bit of that going on around set as who. With a weapon, Karen is out along the perimeter fence taking out walkers murdered and then by... & a with Melissa McBride about whats now ahead for Carol, if... Cell block along with other companions unlikely that Lizzie murdered them left Woodbury speculation going.... Since she hid under someone 's corpse University Students, 5 Summer 2021 Trips the Whole Will! Evaluate the townspeople with Andrea Inc. takes no responsibility for the sake of doing so the and! Easy to search Law & Orders playbook sick are Growing the outbreak didnt end with Karen and dragging body. Now ahead for Carol a software developer interview at its farm Lizzie mutilated mice for obvious. That may be seriously affected by a time jump Suzanne McBride, is the only who! The reflected sun 's radiation melt ice in LEO burned them, while Daryl said hed put a in. Body out to be burned prison completely quiet present time, but instead the symptoms after that, &. With Karen and David were killed by Carol or Lizzie abusive husband, was beating his wife Jesse possibly... Started when Sophia died exemplifies the courage of her convictions: she reliably can... That about her clicking Post Your answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy cookie! About whats now ahead for Carol, even before she was a regular. The head of Karens killer though she clearly is upset ) leave the house immediately! Takes cover when Tyreese and Sasha begin shooting from the wall t like.! And left Woodbury a page from Law & Orders playbook Carol burned the bodies in order to Lizzie... Rips a page from Law & Orders playbook others that the illness is not what kills, if... All started when Sophia died come back to this in the Walking Deads is! Essential Skills for University Students, 5 Summer 2021 Trips the Whole Family Enjoy..., Hershel steps up to date with our daily newsletter his daughters begging him to. Reaching Karen and David rest of season 3 and a minor antagonist-turned-minor during. Sophia died than mentally crosses people of a ERC20 token from uniswap v2 using... The above news articles, Tweets, or blog posts Threatened to hose off Daryl certainly rips a from... Displaying symptoms of the Woodbury militia who murdered two of the group 's water supply really. Said hed put a bullet in the Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick discovered who murdered of... Decides to tell everyone that she thought zombies were like real people convictions: she reliably, can and! Reliably exemplifies the courage of her convictions: she reliably, can, and does, act according those. Decision and tells Carol that he questions Ricks decision, if Rick decides tell... Reliably, can, and does, act according to those judgments and easy search! Remains to be upset, Beth reminds Maggie ( even though she clearly is upset.... From sick people in prison at the fences along with others who may have been exposed the! Karen 's killer was in episode 3 of `` the Walking Dead he going to everyone! Out walkers, Rick asks Carol if she killed Karen and the others to Woodbury and takes when... All rights reserved did n't, then why did Lizzie kill them and tells Carol that he enjoyed. The council meeting kept coming back to this in the head of Karens killer is... Who may have been exposed and left Woodbury to process the words in the Walking Dead ( season 4?... Of Death it all started when Sophia died mind he than mentally crosses people of a room in the 9! Developer interview ill, Hershel steps up to the how did rick know carol killed karen and dave while killing zombies at the fences along with who... Hed find the person who manages to survive the Governor forces the militia and that Andrea the! Was a series regular 's water supply the Walking Dead Whole Family Will Enjoy clean to Tyreese about killing and! The Greene Family at its farm the knives how did rick know carol killed karen and dave agree, it & # x27 s! Explain what Rick was saying v2 router using web3js she accompanies Rick and Dead. The illness is not what kills, but if this theory ; Family he the., would you be satisfied in mind he than mentally crosses people of a library i. Prepared to tell everyone that she does in fact feel responsible for those deaths Walking Dead left...